12th July 2004
Hey Folks --
We're building a small studio here in Northern California, and I'm
trying to calculate our power needs. Since I'm not an electrician,
I'm wondering if you guys can help me.
We shoot mainly simple industrial/corporate stuff. We do a lot of
one person and two person chroma key stuff and some small set shoots.
We have a small grid. Budget IS a limitation. I'm not looking for
a dream set-up, I'm looking for basic requirements.
About the most power intensive set-up I can ever imagine us doing
would be something like below. These lights may not all be burning
at once, but for the sake of planning let's imagine they are :
* 4-6 KinoFlo 4x4's (used to light blue/green screen
and as subject lights)
* 3 or 4 300k-600k fresnels
* 3 Lowell Tota fixture -- (750k each) 2250k
* maybe a 1k fresnel or two
* camera and monitor
* two or three laptop computers
class="style9 style10">* two or three more standard outlets for misc.
audio, practicals, etc.
This doesn't include house lights, those will be on a separate circuit.
How would our power needs change if we ever wanted to punch a big
daylight source like a 5k or something through window of a set?
This would be a nice to have.
Finally, can anyone recommend a console to run some or most of these
lights, with individual dimmable switches. Is that a nice way to
go? How much?
Thanks in advance ...
Daniel Cowles
Dan,
So with that said - Best to hire an electrician to sort out your
needs. It is very difficult to respond adequately and safely to
your request.
I mean I could recommend that you get six 20A circuits without addressing
the 5K or dimmer. The 5K and dimmer changes everything. Perhaps
you need a breakout box off a 200A disconnect but do you have single
phase or 3 phase?
Will you want the chance to use a 2.5K or larger HMI (real daylight
sources)?
You're best bet is to hire a real film electrician to address your
specific needs.
Always hire professionals to do a professional job. Especially when
it comes to electricity.
Jim Sofranko
NY/DP
Thanks Jim --
Good feedback. We are indeed hiring professionals ... I'm not doing
this myself, just trying to make some estimates. I'll pursue this
further with an electrician.
Daniel Cowles
Producer, Macromedia Inc.
San Francisco, CA
A good rule of thumb that allows extra margin for safety and capacity
is to divide the wattage of the instruments to be used by 100. Thus
1800 watts of light needs at least 18 amps or a 20 amp circuit.
The true calculation results in a different number, but as I said,
this way builds in a safety factor, and is good for rough estimates.
Steven Bradford
Collins College
Phoenix AZ
Dan Cowles writes :
>I'll pursue this further with
an electrician.
Also pursue it with the electric company. They may have some experience
with studios.
BTW, your rates etc. may vary greatly depending on the actual amount
(kilowatt hours) of electricity you use at peak times.
It is as Jim Sofranko says not a simple matter, but don't just leave
it to an electrician when you may be paying the bill for a long
time.
Brian Heller
IA 600 DP
>Good feedback. We are indeed
hiring professionals...I'm not doing this >myself, just trying
to make some estimates. I'll pursue this further with >an electrician.
I'm glad you understand as it would be too easy to mislead you.
There are simply too many things to take into consideration.
Generally, a rule of thumb for estimating is 1,000 watts equals
10A (amps). So a 20 amp circuit will take 2,000 watts maximum.
That's as far as I'll take it as it gets too easy to give inappropriate
advice in terms of layout and design.
Best Regards,
Jim Sofranko
NY/DP
A 120 amp box will do more than you need. I have built six insert
stages and that is where I start my power minimums at. Sounds like
you are in the same place.
We don't look at what light you use but what potential you might
need. Usually without a stage my clients are like, you, "here
is what we are doing". But a stage is going to introduce you
to new ideas and eventually someone in your group is going to say
"we ought to get some more permanent lights for the studio"
or "let's do more now that we can".
Walter Graff
BlueSky Media, Inc.
www.bluesky-web.com
Offices in NYC and Amherst Mass.
Dan,
You don't say how big the studio is other than "small".
I suspect studio designers have some guidelines based on floor space
that they apply when figuring out how much total amperage to build
into a studio space. If you are building a 20'x20' stage the possible
extravagance of your power needs and lighting set-ups will be much
lower than if you have a 30'x50' or 70'x70' space.
That said, the lights you describe only total less than 10,000 watts
(83 amps) if used simultaneously. I would always want to have the
option of also bringing in a few 5K's, 6K Space lights or even 10K's
for extreme use of the studio you might not contemplate now i.e.
high speed, table top, deep focus, big source through window, translight
backlighting, etc. Unless the studio is really so small that it
precludes all of the above I'd allow for a generous amount of power
so that you always have options. Of course one possibility is bringing
a generator to the studio on those rare occasions that you exceed
the power design. But that should be allowed for now in the design
and building of the studio so you can bring in your feeder cables
without leaving a door open somewhere. Here in LA stages have special
cable pass-throughs just for that purpose.
While your budget may not allow you to dream, I would anyway, at
least enough so you have options when you finally use your new space.
My 2 centavos worth.
Randy "give me all the power you got, Scotty" Miller,
DP in LA
>At least 600 amps, 3 phase...
At least. Why? Cause you just never know >when you are going
to need it.
This is why I didn't want to get into this too specifically...
A 200 amp, 3 phase service has a total capacity of 600 amps. In
electrical terminology it is called a 200A (amp) 3 phase service.
There is no such thing as a 600 amp service but, as you suggested,
a total of 600 amps may be a good start for a studio. It is very
often considered the minimum. But it truly depends on the needs
of the situation, the existing service, budget, and local electrical
codes.
Sorry to be such a stickler for details but I was a gaffer for too
long and know how easily this terminology gets confused and misunderstood.
Jim Sofranko
NY/DP
>At least 600 amps, 3 phase...
At least. Why? Cause you just never know >when you are going
to need it.
I believe you said this is a 25x25 studio? If so 600 amps is about
480 too many.
Walter Graff
BlueSky Media, Inc.
>There is no such thing as a
600 amp service
That is not true. There is such a thing as any number of service
panels from 100 amp up a 2000 amp service. Requirements, supply
voltage and feeder cabling size determines the limit. It usually
goes 100, 200, 300, and 400 for a residential scenario with 300
usually being the upper norm and 100, 200, 400, 600, 800, 1000,
and 2000 for a commercial service panel. Of course 2000 is not the
limit either, just one of the more standard larger size service
panels that are normally installed. For an insert stage of about
25x25, 200 amp service is the bottom line. With that you can easily
light 16-25 fixtures of the size mentioned in the original post.
The odds of you needing a 5k HMI in this scenario are pretty slim.
You could get the same quality of light in a studio of the size
I mentioned with a 400 watt HMI.
Walter Graff
BlueSky Media, Inc.
Maurice Jordan wrote :
>I agree with Miller... The
more power the better...
Something to consider is the cost of usage, or Non Usage.
Steven Gladstone wrote :
>told me that they paid a huge
electric bill every month whether or not >they used the power,
I was told its not the size of service but the peak draw during
the month.
This is what happened at Cinema World Studio in NYC. Last few times
I shot there, we worked off a 2000amp genny in the yard! I was told
that if they have a heavy draw one day of the month but no draw
the rest of the days they still pay a monthly rate based on that
peak draw (as if they used that amount everyday). Seems like they
got hit for a 10,000 or such bill even though they used little during
a months time except for that one or two day usage.
John Roche,
Gaffer
NYC
John Roche writes :
>I was told its not the size
of service but the peak draw during the month. >This is what
happened at Cinema World Studio in NYC. Last few times I >shot
there, we worked off a 2000amp genny in the yard!
Actually, it's both, and it depends on the size of the service and
the amount of electricity consumed. And it is negotiable.
You may have to agree to a minimum usage in order to get a large
service, or you may have to pay for the entire installation. If
you go over the agreed amount then you will have to pay the higher
rate for the entire billing period. It costs the electric company
to have excess capacity available, and they are in business to make
money. However, if you are a large enough user, they may pay you
not to use a certain amount of power during peak periods.
Many large users have installed generators to use in this "peak
shaving" process.
Brian Heller
IA 600 DP
>There is no such thing as a
600 amp service
>That is not true. There is such a thing as any number of service
panels >from 100 amp up a 2000 amp service.
You're absolutely right about that Walter.
I stand corrected. I was thinking of the service entrance designation
and the difference of the total amps. Oopps.
Thanks for pointing that out.
Jim Sofranko
NY/DP
Copyright © CML. All rights reserved.